
The Women's Electronic
Communications and Action Network


Legislative Priorities

Colorado Women's Legislative Scorecard
|

Colorado Overview
- In 1997, the US Bureau of the Census estimated the poverty rate among elderly women at
13.6%, compared to only 6.8% among elderly men. Women comprise 74% of the poor elderly
population, but only 58% of all elderly. (based on data from the March 1997 Current
Population Survey)
Over the past several decades, significant progress has been made in
reducing poverty among the elderly as a group. However, statistics show that it is
primarily older men who have escaped poverty, while the number of older women living in or
near poverty has actually increased. Older women are now twice as likely as elderly men to
be poor. Although many Americans of both genders still find it difficult to attain
economic security during their later years, advances for older women have been especially
impeded by gender discrimination in traditional patterns of retirement financial
strategies, including Social Security, private pensions, and personal investment. As the
elderly population in Colorado continues to rise, the economic security of our
states older residents becomes increasingly important.
- Women over 65 had an average income of $14,320 in 1997, while men over 65 had an average
income of $25,669. That means that the retirement wage gap is fifty-six cents; or women of
retirement age earn only 44 cents for every dollar a man of the same age receives.
(Employee Benefit Research Institute and March 1997 Current Population Survey)
The social and economic patterns that hamper womens economic
security during their working years the wage gap, lack of value placed on work done
inside the home, and a general gender bias in many public programs, to name a few-- are
magnified during retirement. Few women receive employer-sponsored pensions, and even fewer
are able to live on their pension payments. Private investments are also problematic for
older women, who frequently lack both the resources and the knowledge to begin investing
for themselves. Social Security, which is often the only dependable, permanent
source of income for retired women, also has a number of internal biases against
womens life patterns and needs. To compound these problems, since women on
average live longer than men, their resources need to last longer and are more likely
to be eroded by inflation.
- According to the University of California Institute for Health and Aging, older
womens income from all sources at retirement is 30% of mens.
None of the traditional means of support for the elderly adequately address the needs
of women of retirement age. Changes in employment and pension laws, efforts to educate the
public on private investments, and reforms to social security must specifically focus on
the needs and life patterns of women if Colorado is to improve economic security among all
segments of our growing elderly population.
Elderly Women living in Poverty
In 1994-95, there were 312,000 Colorado residents over the age of 65. 32,000 of them (or
10.3%) lived in poverty. (State Facts: Health Needs and Medicaid Financing, The
Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation)
In 1992, Elderly women (16 percent) had a higher poverty rate than elderly men (9
percent). For both genders, the poverty rate was higher for elderly African-Americans (33
percent) and Hispanics (22 percent) than for whites (11 percent). (US Census Bureau, May
1995 Statistical Brief Sixty-five Plus in the United States)
Elderly Population Growth in Colorado
Between 1990 and 1998, Colorados elderly population grew by 21.4% to a total of
401,784 persons, constituting 10.1% of the states population. (Population Reference
Bureau, October 1999 Population Today)
In 1999, there were 407,773 people over the age of 65 living in Colorado. 57.3% of them
were women. 70% of Coloradans over the age of 85 were women. (US Census Bureau, Population
Division)
By 2020, the US Census Bureau projects that Colorados elderly population will
increase 108% from 1993, to 743,000. (www.census.gov/Press-Release/cb96-80.html)
Pensions
Women lose or reduce the opportunity to amass benefits and pensions for retirement when
they take time off from working outside the home to raise a family.
The Business and Professional Womens Foundation reports that only 39% of all
working women were covered by a pension plan in 1997. Less than 1/3 of currently retired
women receive a pension, compared to 55% of male retirees.
Among new private sector pension annuity recipients in 1993-94, only 30% of women over
65 received a pension, compared to 48% of men. Additionally, womens pensions are
worth only half as much as mens: the median annual benefit for women was $4800,
compared to $9600 for men. ("Women and Retirement Security"National Economic
Council Interagency Working Group on Social Security)
Private Investments
Most retired women have little money to invest, and consequently tend
to gravitate towards low-risk investments that do not result in much gain. The pay gap,
compounded with the added expenses for health, children, and elder care that women pay
over their lives, means that women have a hard time saving enough to provide comfortable
retirement. Additionally, women who have never invested before and/or can not afford to
hire a professional financial consultant are at risk of losing what little money they have
managed to save. Women are also less likely to have invested independently over the course
of their lives, and have little or no experience from which to build. Employer- or
state-sponsored educational efforts, beginning when women enter the work force and
continuing into retirement, could dramatically help future retirees make the most of their
private investments.
Social Security
Overall, elderly women depend on Social Security for 51% of their total income. (Social
Security Administration)
According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 75% of unmarried elderly women
depend on Social Security for the majority of their income; 40% of older women living
alone depend in it for at least 90% of their income; and 25% of all elderly women rely on
Social Security for their financial support. ("Social Security and Poverty Among the
Elderly")
The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities also reports that without Social Security,
more than 52% of elderly women would be living in poverty. Even with Social Security, 13%
of older women are poor, making them nearly twice as likely as older men to live below the
poverty line. ("Social Security and Poverty Among the Elderly.")
Social Security benefits are based on an individuals earnings over 35 years.
However, women who take time off for caregiving and family responsibilities, the median
woman retiring in 1997 had only worked 27 years, compared to 39 years for the median man.
Consequently, womens Social Security benefits are automatically reduced. (Social
Security Administration, Office of Chief Actuary, October 1998)
Longer Lifespans/Women Living Alone
In addition to gender biases in traditional means of subsistence for
retired persons, womens economic problems in later life are substantially compounded
by their longer lifespans.
- While few elderly married couples are poor, more than 22% of divorced women, 18% of
widows, and 20% of never-married women over 65 lived below the poverty line in 1997.
Overall, nearly 60% of all elderly women are unmarried.
- In 1993, elderly women were more than three times as likely as elderly men to be widowed
(48 percent versus 14 percent).
- As women grow older, they are more likely than men to live alone on reduced incomes and
to depend on assistance from friends and relatives. Eighty percent of elderly living alone
nationwide in 1993 were women.
- Among both sexes, the likelihood of living alone increased with age. For women, it rose
from 32 percent for 65- to 74-year-olds to 57 percent for those aged 85 years or more; for
men, the corresponding proportions were 13 percent and 29 percent.
(Source: US Census Bureau, May 1995 Statistical Brief Sixty-five plus in the United
States)
Policy Recommendations:
The protections in the current Social Security system that especially benefit women must
be preserved, including: Guaranteed lifetime benefits and a full cost-of-living adjustment
that ensure that women do not outlive their assets, or see their income reduced by
inflation, no matter how long they live. A progressive benefit formula that helps
lower-income earners, who are disproportionately women. Benefits for children and the
parent who takes care of them, when a working parent becomes disabled or dies prematurely.
Spousal and survivor benefits for married women, divorced women, and widows.
Since Social Security provides almost all retirement income for most women, Social
Security benefits should be changed to reflect the pattern of women's work. Social
Security should offer benefits for time taken to raise a family, as well as time spent in
the workforce.
Provide incentives for employers to offer educational programs on the need for women in
particular to plan for their own retirement, and to encourage employees to take advantage
of additional savings programs (pursuant to the rise of 401(k) plans).
Create a state-sponsored public education program to provide information and assistance
to women of near or retirement age who have been denied benefits.
Increase survivor benefits offered to widows and widowers. This would substantially
mitigate poverty for many elderly widows, who are the poorest part of the population.
Oppose efforts to privatize Social Security, which would unfairly disadvantage those
retired Americans (overwhelmingly women and low-income individuals) who lacked previous
investment experience and/or could not afford professional financial advisors.
Resources
Center for
Policy Alternatives - women-led national agenda
WomansWord
- a feminist activist newsletter, with a detailed explanation of womens use of
and need for Social Security, and arguments against privatization.
Voxcap.com - an online activism
network, provides a continually updated annotated list (including links) of articles on
pensions, retirement and social security, many relating directly to women and minorities.
Social
Security Administration - provides an extensive list and text of publications
regarding policy and womens issues with social security and retirement.
American Association of
Retired Persons - runs a Womens Initiative which addresses the economic, social,
and health needs of mid-life and older women.
Agency
on Aging - offers legal information and resources for the elderly.
National
Older Womens League (OWL) conducts research, education, and advocacy for
older women. Web site provides papers on many issues affecting older women, including
social security, health care, and poverty. Contact the Colorado chapter at 303-446-4079.
Womens Institute for a Secure
Retirement (WISER) Washington-based organization dealing with gender inequities in
federal retirement programs. Contact them at 202-393-5452.
Pension Rights Center #150; Runs a
Womens Pension Project for advocacy, educational, and organizing activites for older
womens security. The PRC is located at 918 16th Street NW, Washington DC
20006.
|
|